← Back to Insights
Insight  •  Issue Remediation

Why the Same Findings Keep Coming Back

A repeat finding is rarely bad luck. More often it is the first fix reporting back.

November 2026    5 min read
How it plays outAn illustration of a year of findings, and what happens when the cause is never reached.
Findings logged this year
One root
cause
Close calendar
✓
Closed
Action plans done. Evidence on file.
Fix the cause once.
Close more than
one finding.
BPSADVISORY
GROUP

The finding was closed in March. By the next audit cycle it was back, worded a little differently, tested on a new sample, carrying a new number. Same problem.

Anyone who has spent a few years in audit has watched this happen. The action plan was completed. The evidence was uploaded. Someone signed off. A year later the team is drafting the same observation again, usually in a slightly firmer tone, because everybody remembers the last one.

It is tempting to treat the second finding as a new event and start over. Most of the time it is the old one, still unresolved, showing up on schedule.

01

A finding that returns says something about the last remediation, and that is worth reading before writing a new action plan.

02

Most repeats trace back to a short list of causes: a fix aimed at the symptom, a fix that lived in one person, or a business that changed underneath it.

03

Read the tracker as a whole. Several open items often share a single cause, and fixing it once can close more than one line.

01

A Repeat Is Telling You Something

When a finding comes back, the first remediation did not change the condition that caused it. Written down, that sounds obvious. In the middle of a busy year it gets lost.

Part of the reason is how issues are tracked. Each finding has its own owner, its own actions and its own due date, and the tracker is very good at recording whether those actions were done. It has much less to say about whether they worked.

Repeats are common, even at the most serious level. In KPMG's review of SEC filings, more than a third of the companies that disclosed a material weakness between 2021 and 2025 reported one in more than one year.

So before drafting a new action plan, it helps to go back to the old one. What did we change last time? Why did that change not hold? The answers are usually more useful than anything in the new finding.

02

Where Repeats Usually Come From

Trace enough repeat findings back to their roots and the same few patterns turn up.

01

The fix went after the symptom

A reconciliation was found without evidence of review, so a second reviewer was added. Nobody asked why the reconciliation took eleven days to prepare, which is the reason the first reviewer never had time to look at it properly.

02

The fix lived in one person

A strong manager tightened the process and the finding closed. Then she moved into a new role. The improved procedure lived in her head and in a few emails, and it left with her.

03

The fix was a cleanup, not a change

A backlog of stale items was cleared and the evidence looked good. Whatever had been creating the backlog kept running, and by the next review it had built up again.

04

The business moved

A new system, an acquisition, a reorganization, a new vendor. The control was fine for the process it was designed around. That process no longer exists in the same form.

None of this means anyone did poor work. Each fix made sense when it was agreed. It answered a narrower question than the one that mattered.

An illustrative example

A company carried a finding on late user access removals for three years. Each year the response was a reminder to managers and a tighter quarterly review, and each year the review still turned up former employees with active accounts. The cause was upstream, in HR. Terminations in two regions were being entered weeks after people had left, so IT never received the trigger in time. Once that timing was fixed, the access finding stopped coming back.

03

One Cause, Several Findings

Repeats are easier to spot when you stop reading findings one at a time.

Pull the open and recently closed items into a single view and look for what they have in common. A late reconciliation in accounts payable, a manual journal entry with thin support, and a vendor master change approved after the fact can look like three separate issues in three separate areas. Sometimes they are one issue: a close calendar that leaves no realistic time for the work to be done well.

When findings that share a cause are handled separately, the result is three action plans, three owners, and three reasons for the problem to come back. Fixing the cause once tends to close more than one line on the tracker, and keeps it closed.

This takes a little more time up front. It also tends to be the only approach that ends the cycle.

A long corridor of stone arches in warm light

Repetition is lovely in architecture. In an issue tracker, it usually means the same cause is still holding everything up.

04

Questions Worth Asking Before the Next Closure

Before calling a finding closed, especially one that has been seen before, a few questions are worth a few minutes:

If the honest answer to any of these is uncertain, the finding may be ready to close on paper and still not ready to stay closed.

Where This Leaves You

A finding that comes back is seldom a failure of effort. Usually the first fix was aimed a little to the side of the real problem.

Putting more effort into the same item rarely helps. What helps is stepping back and asking what the recurring findings have in common, and what would have to change for all of them to stay closed.

The second time a finding appears, it is worth reading less like a new problem and more like a report on the last fix.

Before closing

Five questions

  • Did we change the cause, or only the place where the problem showed up?
  • Would the fix still work if the person who designed it left tomorrow?
  • Is the change written into the procedure, the system or the calendar, or only into the action plan?
  • Has the control run long enough, including through a busy period, to show it holds?
  • Is anything changing in the business over the next year that this fix depends on?
SourcesKPMG, Trends in material weaknesses (2026), based on SEC filings from 2021 to 2025 sourced from Audit Analytics.

Have a Specific Problem to Work Through?

An aging finding, control issue, documentation gap, or workstream short on capacity is enough of a starting point. Tell us what is happening and what you need to be true at the end.

Tell us what is stuck, what changed, or what deadline is driving the need. We can determine whether BPS Advisory Group is the right fit and what a sensible scope would look like.